What happened
Father Issa Thaljieh, the Greek Orthodox parish priest at Bethlehem's Church of the Nativity, says the United States refused him a visa ahead of planned appearances in Maryland and Washington. He said questioning during his embassy interview concentrated on his Palestinian identity, leading him to believe it was the main reason for refusal.S1S2S3
That explanation remains his assessment. The State Department did not give The Jerusalem Post the specific grounds for the decision, instead describing its general approach to screening applicants and enforcing immigration law. Its spokesperson's statement that every visa decision concerns national security does not establish an individual security finding against the priest.S2
Thaljieh had been expected at the Not in Christ's Name conference in Potomac on 14 November and a Christian protest near the US Capitol on 16 November. He said he wanted to discuss life in Bethlehem and challenges facing Palestinian Christians. The Times of India reports that he participated remotely through Zoom.S1S2
Why it matters
There is a broader restriction behind the dispute. State Department guidance confirms a suspension covering immigrant and non-immigrant visas for people using Palestinian Authority-issued or endorsed travel documents, subject to exceptions. Presidential Proclamation 10998 took effect on 1 January 2026; the policy's document-based wording is more specific than a universal prohibition on Palestinian identity.R1S2
A separate claim concerning Lutheran pastor Munther Isaac requires correction. The Vulnerable People Project said he too had been denied a visa, but Isaac said he had not applied. In his statement, reproduced by The Jerusalem Post, he explained that he believed the restrictions made an application unlikely to succeed, citing friends' experiences.S2
The background
The proclamation contains categorical exceptions and allows individual national-interest exceptions. Its list does not include a general exemption for clergy. Those provisions establish possible exceptions within the policy, but do not show whether Thaljieh was assessed for one or whether an exception was refused in his case.R2S2
The State Department also says the proclamation applies to people outside the US on its effective date who lacked a valid visa then. Previously issued valid visas are not revoked under that proclamation. Applicants may still submit applications and attend interviews, even when they may be ineligible to receive a visa.R1
What happens next
The Vulnerable People Project has called on President Donald Trump and Secretary of State Marco Rubio to review and reverse Thaljieh's refusal. The available accounts do not establish that either has agreed to do so. The unresolved questions remain the legal ground used and whether an exception was considered, rather than a confirmed individual ban on religious advocacy.S2