High spin · most spun: New York Post 68/100 See every outlet’s spin ↓Photo as used by New York Post for “Plane makes terrifying landing at Heathrow Airport as screaming passengers heard from inside”How New York Post framed it: The New York Post's lead image shows the aircraft pitched nose-up close to the runway, with smoke visible near the ground. Alongside the headline, the dramatic moment reinforces the impression of a frightening landing attempt.
British Airways says an aircraft landed safely and that it is assisting an AAIB investigation after a reported tail strike at Heathrow. Reports identify the flight as BA431 from Amsterdam on 12 November. The cause has not been established by the evidence reviewed.
How the coverage differs
All three outlets foreground the tail strike and reported passenger fear, though only a headline and truncated summary are available for The Sun. Only the Daily Mirror's supplied text reports that the aircraft landed safely on a second attempt and was taken out of service for engineering checks. The New York Post alone includes a reported suggestion of cockpit misjudgement and an unrelated United Airlines security incident. None of the supplied texts includes Airbus's near-ground go-around guidance or its figures for 49 reported tail strikes.
British Airways says it is assisting the Air Accidents Investigation Branch after reports that flight BA431 struck its tail on the runway during a landing attempt at Heathrow. The Airbus A321neo was arriving from Amsterdam on Thursday, 12 November, according to the Sun and reports repeating its account.S1S2S3
The Mirror reports that the aircraft climbed away and landed on a second attempt, then was removed from service for engineering checks. In a statement to the Sun reproduced by the Mirror, British Airways said the aircraft had landed safely. The airline said it was legally unable to comment further while assisting the investigation.S2
The coverage describes footage recorded by a plane spotter near the airport. Accounts of passengers screaming and moving forward in their seats came from sources quoted by the Sun and were subsequently repeated elsewhere. Those accounts describe reported reactions aboard; they do not establish the technical cause.S1S2S3
Why it matters
The distinction between an observed sequence and a finding about responsibility is important here. The New York Post repeats an assertion that early inquiries pointed to a cockpit misjudgement, but provides no published investigation finding supporting it. The material reviewed does not establish pilot error, a mechanical fault or the precise contribution of weather.S1S2
The AAIB describes its role as determining the circumstances and causes of civil aircraft accidents and serious incidents, and promoting action to prevent recurrence. Its reports explain what happened without attributing blame. The branch is an independent unit within the Department for Transport, with operations, engineering and flight-data specialists among its inspectors.R1
The background
Airbus safety guidance explains that a go-around close to the ground can involve a risk of tail contact. It says brief landing-gear contact with the runway can occur during the manoeuvre, and warns against excessive nose-up inputs. That guidance describes general operating risks; it is not an assessment of the actions of the BA431 crew.R2
Airbus recorded 49 reported tail-strike events between January 2022 and September 2024: five on take-off, 23 during landing and 21 during a go-around near the ground. They do not provide the cause of Thursday’s incident or a probability for an individual flight.R2
What happens next
The reported engineering checks and the airline’s assistance to investigators are the concrete follow-up steps described in the coverage. A technical explanation, the extent of any damage and a timetable for returning the aircraft to service remain unestablished in the material reviewed. The published airline statement does not supply an investigation conclusion or make a finding about the crew.S2
Fact check: every point labelled
What is confirmed, what is only reported, and what is claim or speculation. Every point links to its source.
What we know
On the record or independently reported by more than one outlet.
confirmedAAIB investigates circumstances and causes, promotes prevention and reports without attributing blame. It is an independent DfT unit with operations, engineering and flight-data specialists.R1
confirmedAirbus guidance describes tail-strike risk during near-ground go-arounds, possible brief landing-gear contact and the need to avoid excessive nose-up inputs.R2
confirmedAirbus recorded 49 reported tail strikes from January 2022 to September 2024: five on take-off, 23 during landing and 21 during near-ground go-arounds.R2
Reported but not yet confirmed
Reported as fact, but from a single origin.
reportedThe Sun and outlets repeating its account: BA431, an Airbus A321neo from Amsterdam, reportedly suffered a tail strike during a Heathrow landing attempt on 12 November.S1S2S3
reportedDaily Mirror: The aircraft climbed away, landed on a second attempt and was removed from service for engineering checks.S2
reportedThe Sun, as relayed by the Mirror and New York Post: Plane-spotter footage captured the incident; sources described screams and passengers lurching forward.S1S2S3
reportedNew York Post relaying The Sun: Early inquiries pointed to cockpit misjudgement.S1
Claims and disputes
What people say. Not established fact.
claimedBritish Airways: The aircraft landed safely; the airline was assisting the AAIB and said it could not legally comment further.S2
Still unknown
The established cause and extent of damage.
The aircraft's return-to-service timetable.
Key questions
Which flight was involved?
Reports identify BA431, an Airbus A321neo travelling from Amsterdam to Heathrow on 12 November.S1S2S3
Did the aircraft land safely?
British Airways said it did. The Mirror reports that it landed on a second attempt.S2
Has pilot error been established?
The reviewed material does not establish the cause. British Airways says it is assisting the AAIB.S1S2
Spin meter
How each outlet framed this story, scored on the wording and choices in that article, not on the outlet’s reputation.
Headlines compared: The New York Post and the Daily Mirror lead with a terrifying landing and reported screams, while The Sun foregrounds the tail scraping the runway. All three use emotionally charged language rather than leading with the subsequent safe landing.
New York PostFraming: Not political · Spin 68/100 · Headline matches story: yes
“Plane makes terrifying landing at Heathrow Airport as screaming passengers heard from inside”
Straight reportingHeavy spin
The New York Post framed the tail strike as a frightening near-crash, emphasising passengers' reactions and a reported suggestion of cockpit error.
Why? 7 framing techniques
loaded languageThe horror landing This describes the incident in dramatic terms rather than simply reporting the tail strike and aborted landing.
emotional appealscreaming could be heard coming from the 220 passengers The emphasis on passengers' fear makes their reported reaction central to the account.
unnamed sourcesa source told The Sun An unidentified source supplies the account of screams and describes the incident as a near-crash.
speculation as factearly investigations pointed to a “misjudgment” in the cockpit The reported suggestion of cockpit error is included without a named investigative source or a finding establishing the cause.
omission The New York Post does not report the subsequent safe landing or engineering checks included by the Daily Mirror.
omission The New York Post omits Airbus's guidance on near-ground go-around tail-strike risks and its reported tail-strike figures.
emphasisa United Airlines flight sent out a hijack alert earlier this week An unrelated aircraft security incident adds further alarming aviation material without explaining the Heathrow tail strike.
Daily MirrorFraming: Not political · Spin 48/100 · Headline matches story: yes
“British Airways passengers scream in horror during terrifying landing at Heathrow Airport”
Straight reportingHeavy spin
The Daily Mirror led with passengers' reported fear but also included the safe second landing, engineering checks and British Airways' response.
Why? 4 framing techniques
loaded languageits tail smashed into the runway The verb gives the reported tail strike a particularly forceful and dramatic character.
emotional appealpassengers scream in horror The headline foregrounds passengers' reported fear rather than the aircraft's subsequent safe landing.
unnamed sourcesThe Sun reports a source onboard The passenger account and characterisation of the event as a near-crash come from an unnamed source reported by another outlet.
omission The Daily Mirror does not include Airbus's guidance on tail-strike risks during near-ground go-arounds or its reported tail-strike figures.
The SunFraming: Not political · Spin 30/100 · Headline matches story: yes
“Terrifying moment packed BA flight’s tail scrapes along runway as plane comes in to land at Heathrow”
Straight reportingHeavy spin
The Sun's available headline and summary emphasised the dramatic landing attempt and reported screams from passengers.
Why? 3 framing techniques
loaded languageterrifying landing scare The summary uses an emotionally charged description for the reported aborted landing.
emphasisScreams were heard from up to 220 passengers onboard The summary foregrounds reported passenger reactions to convey the drama of the incident.
unnamed sourcesaccording to sources The summary attributes the reported screams to sources whose identities are not given in the excerpt.
Earlier coverage of similar events
How outlets reported related stories before this one. Compare for yourself.
This story was written and checked by AI agents using only the sources above, then published automatically. Facts are labelled by how well they are supported. If something is wrong, tell us: we check every report against the sources and publish corrections. Editorial policy