What happened

Advice attributed to The Ceiling Fan Company in the Mirror and Express promotes using ceiling fans during winter to redistribute warm air. Both reports suggest that reversing the fan could cut energy bills by up to 10%. They refer to research without identifying a study or explaining its conditions.S1S2

The reports also say air near a ceiling can be up to 30 degrees warmer than air near the floor. Neither specifies a temperature scale or provides measurements from a named study. The figure therefore comes without the information needed to establish where it applies.S1S2

Why it matters

There is official support for using a reversible ceiling fan in cold weather. The US Department of Energy recommends a slow clockwise setting to move warm air from the ceiling towards people below. Its guidance says the fan itself does not change the room's temperature.R1

Ontario's Save on Energy programme explains the possible saving through the heating controls. It says circulating heat supplied by a furnace can allow the thermostat to be lowered while occupants remain comfortable. Its explanation concerns using existing heat more effectively, rather than a fixed percentage saving.R2

A separate claim in the newspaper advice concerns the electricity used by the fan motor. It says low-energy DC motors use 60% less electricity than conventional versions. That is presented as a comparison between motors, not a measurement of a household's total winter heating bill.S1S2

Energy Star makes its own efficiency comparison for certified ceiling fans with lights. It describes those products as 60% more efficient than conventional fan-and-light units. This comparison concerns the appliance being certified, rather than promising that percentage off a home's heating costs.R4

The background

The seasonal settings serve different purposes. Save on Energy describes anticlockwise rotation in summer as producing a cooling breeze, while the US Department of Energy's winter guidance calls for clockwise rotation at low speed to recirculate warmth. The newspaper advice similarly stresses avoiding a cooling draught in winter.S1R2R1

Settings also depend on the equipment and room. Minka-Aire's Seacrest manual identifies room size, ceiling height and the number of fans as factors affecting the appropriate speed. The newspaper advice says direction controls vary, with a switch on some models and a remote control on others.S1R3

What happens next

The company advises removing dust from the blades before the seasonal change. The Minka manual adds a specific instruction for cleaning: switch the fan off and wait until its blades have stopped. Energy Star's winter guidance also tells users to switch the fan off when leaving the room.S1R3R4