What happened

Former Australia bowler Chadd Sayers said on 15 November that he carried sandpaper off the field during the second Test of the 2018 South Africa tour, at Port Elizabeth. He told SEN he believed everyone in the team knew it was being used. Pat Cummins has denied knowing sandpaper was being taken onto the field or helping devise a tampering scheme.S3S7R1

Sayers said sandpaper was used in two Tests and that players discussed how to make the ball reverse swing. He also recalled a dressing-room discussion lasting 60 to 90 minutes after the Cape Town incident, about what had happened and collective responsibility. Cummins said on Friday that he did not remember such a conversation or a meeting where Usman Khawaja proposed accepting responsibility together.S3S4R1R5

Cricket Australia responded on Sunday that it respected players' right to give their accounts. It said the differences made agreement very unlikely without relevant material evidence. That was its assessment of the prospects for resolving the dispute, rather than a finding that Sayers's account was established.S5

Why it matters

The full SEN interview includes limits to Sayers's recollection. He said his memory was less clear after eight years and could not recall whose idea the plan originally was. Asked who handed him the sandpaper, he said he assumed it was Cameron Bancroft. Those qualifications distinguish what he recalls doing from what he believes others knew.R1S1

Sayers also said he was never interviewed in the investigation, despite expecting to be. Separately, David Warner clarified on Sunday that he had not been told the bowlers were interviewed or had supplied statements. His earlier criticism had questioned whether Josh Hazlewood, Mitchell Starc and Nathan Lyon were interviewed, conditional on his own understanding being correct. ABC Sport reports that the bowlers were interviewed; Cummins has said he personally was.S4S7R1R5

Khawaja's memoir, Sabr, renewed the disagreement, and Warner supports his account of wider knowledge. In a joint 2021 statement, Cummins, Starc, Hazlewood and Lyon said they learned of the foreign substance from the stadium screen. These remain conflicting accounts of who knew about the plan and when.S7R3

The background

Bancroft was filmed using sandpaper during the March 2018 Cape Town Test against South Africa. Cricket Australia subsequently suspended Steve Smith and Warner for 12 months each, and Bancroft for nine months. Those domestic penalties were separate from the ICC's disciplinary response.R2R4R6

The ICC's contemporary account distinguishes the attempt from its observed effect. Umpires found no marks demonstrating a direct change caused by Bancroft, so they did not replace the ball or impose five penalty runs. They nevertheless judged his actions likely to alter its condition.R2

A separate Ethics Centre review criticised a focus on winning without sufficiently considering its costs and argued that responsibility extended beyond the sanctioned players. Cricket Australia's summary said the review rejected the simpler description of a policy of winning at all costs. These were cultural assessments, not findings establishing each player's prior knowledge.R4R6

What happens next

On 10 November, Cricket Australia chief executive Todd Greenberg said the organisation saw no compelling reason to reopen the inquiry after considering Khawaja's account. Sunday's response highlighted the lack of agreement. What material evidence could resolve the competing accounts remains unanswered.R3S5