What happened

David Samson has urged ESPN to replace Troy Aikman before the network’s first Super Bowl broadcast. Speaking on Friday’s Nothing Personal with David Samson podcast, the former Marlins president argued that reported tension between Aikman and Joe Buck risked distracting from the game.S1

Samson’s proposal is his assessment of what ESPN should do. The New York Post reported no indication that Aikman’s Super Bowl role was in jeopardy, while ESPN chairman Jimmy Pitaro has publicly said he expects the pair’s work to continue through the game.S1

Why it matters

Samson argued that choosing a replacement now would give audiences and the media time to adjust before the play-offs. He said ESPN had invested too much in its first Super Bowl to allow a foreseeable distraction to dominate the build-up.S1

Pitaro offered a different assessment on Tuesday. He described recent coverage as disappointing but praised the commentators’ professionalism and their latest Monday broadcast. His expectation of continued quality through the Super Bowl was a forecast about their work, rather than an announcement of a change.S1

ESPN’s October announcement named Buck, Aikman, Lisa Salters and Laura Rutledge for its planned coverage on 14 February 2027. The company said the traditional broadcast would be available on ESPN, ABC and Disney+ in the United States, alongside a Spanish-language presentation.R1

The background

The contractual positions of the two commentators differ. The Post reported that Buck received a six-year extension worth $108 million, while Aikman was completing his existing contract without a new agreement. It also described an exchange between them before October’s Bills–Rams broadcast.S1

Aikman’s latest remark came during a radio exchange about working alone. Barrett Media reported that George Dunham was hosting The Musers on The Ticket in Dallas without Craig Miller, who was ill. Asked about filling in, Aikman joked about Buck wanting a solo booth, then asked whether Dunham wanted a solo radio show.R2

The partnership predates their current ESPN contracts. ESPN’s account of Aikman’s career says he and Buck began working together in 2002 with Cris Collinsworth, before becoming a duo in 2005. Aikman had spent 20 years at Fox Sports before joining ESPN.R3

What happens next

Samson also said Pitaro should speak to Aikman about professionalism for the rest of the season. He predicted Aikman would not call the Super Bowl. That remains Samson’s prediction; the sources reviewed contain no announcement of a replacement. He warned that viewers might scrutinise the pair’s expressions during the broadcast, interpreting their body language through reports of a disagreement.S1