Some spin · most spun: WalesOnline 48/100 See every outlet’s spin ↓Photo as used by WalesOnline for “Prevent ice forming on car windows overnight with one free item”How WalesOnline framed it: WalesOnline’s lead image shows a red car covered in frost across its windscreen, roof and side windows. It illustrates the scale of the winter problem, though the suggested towel would cover only the windscreen.
Two motoring reports quote the same suggestion to cover the front windscreen before frost forms. The RAC recommends shelter or a fitted cover. The Highway Code sets out what drivers must check before setting off.
How the coverage differs
Both WalesOnline and the Daily Express lead on the towel suggestion, quote Carcone in the same words and include RAC advice on garages, parking near a home and cardboard. Both note that wet cardboard can cause a mess, but neither reports a towel test, a working temperature or a measured time saving. Neither explains that a windscreen cover leaves other windows exposed or mentions the Highway Code’s requirements to clear all windows and mirrors.
An old towel laid over the outside of a parked car’s windscreen could save time scraping it the next morning, according to Jonathan Carcone of 4 Brothers Buy Houses. He suggested holding it in place with the wipers, or using a windscreen cover for the same purpose.S1S2
The Daily Express and WalesOnline both carried the suggestion on 18 November. Both quoted Carcone’s advice in the same words. Neither report described a test of the towel, gave a temperature at which it had worked or measured the time a driver might save.S1S2
Why it matters
For somebody parking outside, the important limit is how much of the car the cover protects. A cover across the front glass leaves the rear and side windows exposed. Even a driver who lifts it off to find a clear windscreen still has other glass and mirrors to check before moving the car.R1R2
Rule 229 of the Highway Code for Great Britain requires drivers to be able to see and tells them to clear snow and ice from every window before setting off. It also calls for clear mirrors and thoroughly demisted glass. Clearing the outside alone will leave the driver with a restricted view if the glass is misted inside.R1
The background
The reports also quote advice about using a garage where one is available, or putting a piece of dry cardboard over the windscreen. Both include a qualification about cardboard. Rain overnight could soak it and leave material on the glass for the driver to clear away in the morning.S1S2
The RAC’s own winter guide describes a fitted cover for the whole vehicle, as well as smaller covers for the windscreen and door mirrors. It says sheltering the vehicle in a garage can also help. Even with a full cover, the guide says drivers may still need the air conditioning and windscreen heaters.R2
What happens next
If ice remains, the RAC advises using the car’s defrost setting and an ice scraper, and checking the wipers are free of ice before switching them on to clear the windscreen. It warns against pouring boiling water on cold glass because the sudden change in temperature can crack it.R2
Before leaving, the Highway Code also requires drivers to check that the lights are clean and that number plates can be seen and read. It tells them to remove snow that could fall into another road user’s path and to check their route for delays or further severe weather.R1
Fact check: every point labelled
What is confirmed, what is only reported, and what is claim or speculation. Every point links to its source.
What we know
On the record or independently reported by more than one outlet.
confirmedThe Daily Express and WalesOnline both carried the suggestion on 18 November.S1S2
confirmedBoth quoted Carcone’s advice in the same words.S1S2
confirmedNeither report described a test of the towel, gave a temperature at which it had worked or measured the time a driver might save.S1S2
confirmedFor somebody parking outside, the important limit is how much of the car the cover protects.R1R2
confirmedA cover across the front glass leaves the rear and side windows exposed.R1R2
confirmedEven a driver who lifts it off to find a clear windscreen still has other glass and mirrors to check before moving the car.R1R2
confirmedRule 229 of the Highway Code for Great Britain requires drivers to be able to see and tells them to clear snow and ice from every window before setting off.R1
confirmedIt also calls for clear mirrors and thoroughly demisted glass.R1
confirmedClearing the outside alone will leave the driver with a restricted view if the glass is misted inside.R1
confirmedThe RAC’s own winter guide describes a fitted cover for the whole vehicle, as well as smaller covers for the windscreen and door mirrors.R2
confirmedIt says sheltering the vehicle in a garage can also help.R2
confirmedEven with a full cover, the guide says drivers may still need the air conditioning and windscreen heaters.R2
confirmedIf ice remains, the RAC advises using the car’s defrost setting and an ice scraper, and checking the wipers are free of ice before switching them on to clear the windscreen.R2
confirmedIt warns against pouring boiling water on cold glass because the sudden change in temperature can crack it.R2
confirmedBefore leaving, the Highway Code also requires drivers to check that the lights are clean and that number plates can be seen and read.R1
confirmedIt tells them to remove snow that could fall into another road user’s path and to check their route for delays or further severe weather.R1
Reported but not yet confirmed
Reported as fact, but from a single origin.
reportedWalesOnline and Daily Express: The reports also quote advice about using a garage where one is available, or putting a piece of dry cardboard over the windscreen.S1S2
reportedWalesOnline and Daily Express: Both include a qualification about cardboard.S1S2
reportedWalesOnline and Daily Express: Rain overnight could soak it and leave material on the glass for the driver to clear away in the morning.S1S2
Claims and disputes
What people say. Not established fact.
claimedJonathan Carcone: An old towel laid over the outside of a parked car’s windscreen could save time scraping it the next morning, according to Jonathan Carcone of 4 Brothers Buy Houses.S1S2
claimedJonathan Carcone: He suggested holding it in place with the wipers, or using a windscreen cover for the same purpose.S1S2
Still unknown
Neither report measures how much scraping time a towel saves.
Key questions
Did either report test the towel?
Both quoted Carcone. Neither described a test.S1S2
What if it rains on a cardboard cover?
The reports warn that wet cardboard could leave residue on the windscreen.S1S2
Which windows must be clear?
The Highway Code directs drivers to clear all their windows of snow and ice before setting off.R1
Spin meter
How each outlet framed this story, scored on the wording and choices in that article, not on the outlet’s reputation.
Headlines compared: Both headlines promise to stop ice forming on car windows overnight while withholding the item’s identity. WalesOnline stresses that it is free; the Daily Express calls it simple.
WalesOnlineFraming: Not political · Spin 48/100 · Headline matches story: partly
“Prevent ice forming on car windows overnight with one free item”
Straight reportingHeavy spin
WalesOnline frames the towel as an easy way to avoid windscreen ice, while mentioning alternative RAC advice and a drawback of cardboard.
Why? 4 framing techniques
clickbait headlinewith one free item The headline withholds the towel’s identity and suggests protection for car windows generally, although the advice concerns the windscreen.
emphasisno scraping required The claim emphasises avoiding scraping without explaining that other windows and mirrors may still need clearing.
omission The report omits the limits of a windscreen cover and Highway Code requirements to clear every window and the mirrors.
omission The report provides no test, working temperature or measured time saving for the towel.
Daily ExpressFraming: Not political · Spin 48/100 · Headline matches story: partly
“Stop ice forming on car windows overnight by using one simple item”
Straight reportingHeavy spin
The Daily Express frames the towel as a simple answer to an irritating winter task, alongside RAC alternatives and a warning about wet cardboard.
Why? 5 framing techniques
clickbait headlineby using one simple item The headline withholds the item’s identity and suggests protection for car windows generally, although the advice concerns the windscreen.
loaded languagethe temperature in the UK has plummeted The dramatic wording heightens the sense of urgency around the cold weather.
emphasisgrabbing a towel could be all you need The wording stresses simplicity without explaining that other glass and mirrors may still need attention.
omission The report omits the limits of a windscreen cover and Highway Code requirements to clear every window and the mirrors.
omission The report provides no test, working temperature or measured time saving for the towel.
Earlier coverage of similar events
How outlets reported related stories before this one. Compare for yourself.
Help power NoDirection. Read without adverts.Your support helps cover our AI costs and ongoing development—improving how we compare coverage, check sources and explain the news.from £3 a month, no adverts while signed inThanks for powering NoDirection. You’re reading without adverts.
This story was written and checked by AI agents using only the sources above, then published automatically. Facts are labelled by how well they are supported. If something is wrong, tell us: we check every report against the sources and publish corrections. Editorial policy