What happened

Two separate estimates of the cost of reversing Brexit have entered the debate before Andy Burnham's planned summit with the EU on 20 November. Campaign group Stay Out claims membership would require £39.3bn in annual contributions, presented as about £750m a week. The Daily Express separately reports a Growth Commission estimate that rejoining would leave the average household £6,500 worse off within ten years.S1S2S3

Those figures describe different things. Stay Out's number concerns payments into the EU budget, while the Growth Commission's figure comes from modelling broader economic effects of rules and regulations. Neither is a bill already agreed between the UK and EU, and the reported estimates should not be treated as interchangeable measures. The payments estimate also does not establish a net cost after any EU funding returned to Britain; the amount the UK might receive is not established.S1S2

Why it matters

Stay Out's calculation assumes the UK would return without its former rebate. Its chairman, Oliver Lewis, argues that a larger EU budget and borrowing costs would make membership more expensive. These are the campaign's assumptions about future membership, rather than terms announced by negotiators.S2S3

The European Commission's own proposal is for almost €2tn across 2028–34, equivalent to 1.26% of average EU gross national income over that period. Its announcement describes a proposal requiring negotiation before adoption. That percentage describes the proposed overall EU budget, rather than a published calculation of a returning UK's contribution.R1

The background

The Express says the Growth Commission also models household losses of £4,820 from joining the European Economic Area and £2,300 from joining the customs union. Its preferred option is to improve the existing Trade and Cooperation Agreement while pursuing regulatory reform. The reported results depend on its treatment of EU regulation and the alternatives being compared.S1

Labour told the Express that the study rests on highly speculative assumptions. A government spokesperson said the deals being negotiated would reduce costs and support growth, while maintaining manifesto red lines. Those assurances are also forecasts; they do not independently settle the competing estimates of future economic effects.S1

The EU budget itself has been contested. A European Parliament research briefing dated 4 November records that leaders did not endorse the Irish presidency's budget proposal at their October meeting. It describes substantial disagreement over the total and how spending should be distributed.R2

What happens next

The government says Burnham will set out further steps on the longer-term relationship after the summit. The Express reports its current red lines as no return to the single market or customs union, and no restoration of free movement, before a general election. The forthcoming talks and hypothetical full membership are therefore different policy questions.S1