What happened

A jury in Ocala, Florida, has heard the prosecution’s opening account of the death of Sonia Exelby, a 32-year-old woman from Southsea in Portsmouth. Dwain Hall denies first-degree murder and kidnapping. The charges are allegations and Hall is presumed innocent. The jury has yet to decide the case.S1S2S3S4R1R2

Assistant state attorney Amy Berndt told the court that Hall and Exelby had met online before Exelby travelled to Florida in October last year. Berndt alleged that Hall had manipulated her and was responsible for her death. That is the prosecution’s account of their contact and its significance.S2S3

Why it matters

The disappearance was initially reported in England. Hampshire and Isle of Wight Constabulary said it received a report on Sunday 12 October 2025 that Exelby was missing from her Southsea home. Its officers established that she had already left the UK by the time they were contacted.R1S3

Her body was found in Marion County, Florida, on 17 October, five days after the missing person report in Britain. In July this year the Hampshire force said it was assisting the Florida Department of Law Enforcement. It described its own role as liaising with the US authorities and providing specialist support to Exelby’s family at home.R1

The background

At the family’s request the force also released a tribute. Her relatives described Exelby as the youngest of six siblings and recalled the music she shared with the family. She played the piano, sang and taught music to her nieces and nephews. They spoke of her close relationship with her sister Sara and her partner of 15 years, Stevie.R1

Her relatives said they wanted people to remember the life she lived. They recalled her concern for animals and the ease she had in making those around her feel accepted. Their statement was released before the trial, in July, while detectives on both sides of the Atlantic were still in contact.R1

What happens next

The stage the Florida proceedings have reached matters to how the allegations are reported. Under Florida’s standard criminal jury instructions, an opening address gives lawyers an opportunity to outline what they expect the trial evidence to show. The document setting out a charge is itself no proof that the charge is true.R2

Jurors must decide the facts from the evidence presented at trial and apply the law as directed by the judge. The burden of proving the charges beyond a reasonable doubt lies with the state. The descriptions used by counsel in the opening address are submissions to the jury.R2S3