What happened

Donald Trump appeared to close his eyes briefly as Chinese President Xi Jinping addressed leaders in Shenzhen on Thursday. The Daily Express described a close-up, shared by the BBC, of the US president sitting behind a desk with microphones as Xi spoke in Chinese.S1S2

In the sequence described by the Express, Trump’s head moved slightly and his eyelids then lifted enough for his eyes to be visible. The report identified the setting as a plenary session attended by leaders including Anthony Albanese of Australia and Mark Carney of Canada.S1

Why it matters

Both accounts interpreted the pictures as possibly showing Trump dozing. The Express described the position of his head and eyelids during a short passage of Xi’s speech. Those movements alone do not establish whether the president fell asleep during the speech.S1S2

The account of the live feed also described other leaders in the room. It said Russian President Vladimir Putin was looking towards the proceedings, while Carney and Hong Kong leader John Lee were taking notes. The Express placed the footage at the plenary. Trump, Xi and Putin were scheduled to meet separately.S2S1

The background

Xi’s published remarks set out what he was asking leaders to do at the 33rd APEC Economic Leaders’ Meeting on 19 November. He called for fewer barriers to trade and investment and for more cooperation between scientists. He also asked members to make it easier to turn research into commercial products.R1

On trade, Xi described a free trade area across the Asia-Pacific as a shared ambition. He proposed closer alignment between regional trade agreements and more technical cooperation so economies could participate. On transport, he urged members to improve infrastructure and customs systems. He also called for easier cross-border payments and travel.R1

Xi also asked members to bring policies and regulations into closer alignment and to keep industrial and supply chains stable across the region.R1

What happens next

Trump has said he wants a new nuclear arms agreement that includes China. The last US-Russian pact, New START, expired in February, the Express reported. The planned talks were separate from Xi’s remarks to the plenary on economic cooperation.S1R1

Daryl Kimball, executive director of the Arms Control Association, said a leaders’ meeting might begin a process leading to sustained talks on reducing nuclear arsenals. He cautioned against expecting a major breakthrough from one encounter and argued that reaching an agreement would require more than photographs of the three presidents together.S1