Prince Harry and five other claimants have asked the Court of Appeal for permission to challenge two High Court rulings. Mr Justice Nicklin dismissed their unlawful information-gathering claims in July and subsequently ordered costs to be assessed on an indemnity basis. Permission to appeal has not been reported as granted.
What happened
Prince Harry and five other claimants applied on 6 November for permission to appeal after losing their privacy case against Associated Newspapers Limited, publisher of the Daily Mail and Mail on Sunday. Court staff confirmed that an application challenging the rulings had been filed.S1S2
The six are Harry, Baroness Doreen Lawrence, Sir Elton John, David Furnish, Elizabeth Hurley and Sadie Frost. Their spokesperson said they were challenging both the dismissal of their claims and the subsequent indemnity costs order. The group considers the decisions legally and factually flawed, the spokesperson said.S1S2S3
This is an application for permission, rather than confirmation that an appeal will be heard. The original trial involved seven claimants, including Sir Simon Hughes. He was not named in the six-person announcement, and the BBC said it had asked whether he would join the challenge.R1R2S1
Why it matters
The applications concern both the outcome of the case and the basis for calculating the publisher’s recoverable legal costs. In August, Nicklin ordered an initial payment of £9,544,355 towards those costs, with the total to be determined separately. That payment was not a final bill.S2S3R4
Under indemnity assessment, proportionality no longer limits recovery, and doubts about whether costs are reasonable are resolved in favour of the party receiving payment. But the court’s summary makes clear that this does not mean every cost is automatically recoverable. Nicklin declined to impose a cap on the recoverable amount.R4
The judge also said the indemnity order was not imposed simply because the claimants had lost. He cited a combination of factors, including the breadth of the case and the continued pursuit of allegations he found lacked an adequate evidential foundation. He made no finding that any claimant had acted dishonestly.R3
The background
The claims were heard during an 11-week trial in London. The claimants alleged unlawful methods including voicemail interception, landline tapping and obtaining information by deception. Associated Newspapers denied the allegations, and Nicklin dismissed all seven claimants’ cases in July.S1S2S3
In his written judgment, Nicklin said unlawful sourcing could not be inferred where a legitimate and realistic route to the information remained. He accepted journalists’ denials and their explanations of lawful sourcing. The publisher’s lawyers said sources included friends, social contacts, press officers and material already published elsewhere.S2S3
What happens next
The immediate issue is whether the Court of Appeal gives permission for either ruling to be challenged. The supplied reports do not give a date for that decision or establish that permission has been granted. The final recoverable costs also remain to be agreed or assessed separately.R1R4S1S2S3
Spin meter
How each outlet framed this story, scored on the wording and choices in that article, not on the outlet’s reputation.
Headlines compared: BBC News and The Guardian highlight that Harry is joined by others and describe a challenge to the ruling. Reuters says he seeks to appeal, whereas The i Paper and Sky News say he is to appeal, without making the permission stage clear in their headlines.
The i PaperFraming: Not political · Spin 17/100 · Headline matches story: partly
“Prince Harry to appeal after losing privacy case against Daily Mail publisher”
Straight reportingHeavy spin
The i Paper focuses on Harry’s allegations and the judge’s rejection of them, while disclosing its shared ownership with the publisher’s parent company.
Why? 3 framing techniques
clickbait headlinePrince Harry to appeal
The headline suggests an appeal will proceed, whereas the article reports an application for permission to appeal.
emphasisEach of the 14 articles that made up Harry’s claims
The article devotes particular attention to Harry’s individual allegations, rather than the other applicants’ cases.
omission The i Paper mentions Sir Simon Hughes as a trial claimant but does not say he was absent from the six-person appeal announcement.
BBC NewsFraming: Not political · Spin 15/100 · Headline matches story: yes
“Harry and five others seek to challenge Mail publisher privacy ruling”
Straight reportingHeavy spin
BBC News frames the application around the high-profile claimants, their potential costs and Sir Simon Hughes’s absence from the announcement.
Why? 2 framing techniques
emphasisjoint legal costs of up to £34.5m
The opening foregrounds a potential costs figure, while the ordered initial contribution was £9.54m and final costs remained undetermined.
omission The BBC does not explain why Nicklin ordered indemnity costs or that he made no finding of dishonesty by any claimant.
The GuardianFraming: Not political · Spin 12/100 · Headline matches story: yes
“Prince Harry and others seek to challenge ruling in Daily Mail privacy case”
Straight reportingHeavy spin
The Guardian emphasises the size of the legal bill and the contrasting reactions to the judgment, while explaining the judge’s approach to lawful sourcing.
Why? 2 framing techniques
emphasisfaced a legal bill of more than £50m
The early emphasis on a large legal bill contrasts with the separately identified initial contribution, which was not the final recoverable costs total.
omission The Guardian does not mention that Sir Simon Hughes was the seventh original claimant and was not named in the six-person appeal announcement.
Sky NewsFraming: Not political · Spin 10/100 · Headline matches story: unknown
“Prince Harry to appeal after privacy lawsuit against Daily Mail publisher dismissed”
Straight reportingHeavy spin
Sky News frames the development around Harry’s intended appeal following the dismissal of the lawsuit.
Why? 1 framing technique
emphasisPrince Harry to appeal
The headline suggests an appeal will proceed without distinguishing the application for permission from permission being granted.
ReutersFraming: Not political · Spin 3/100 · Headline matches story: unknown
“Prince Harry seeks to appeal Daily Mail lawsuit, lawyer says - Reuters”
Straight reportingHeavy spin
Reuters presents Harry’s attempt to appeal in a brief headline attributed to a lawyer.