What happened

Usman Khawaja says he waited until Steve Smith had finished a Test in South Africa before speaking to him about the ball-tampering allegations in his autobiography, Sabr. Describing the conversation on the They Used To Be podcast, Khawaja called it awkward. His account does not establish Smith's recollection of that private exchange.S1S2

Khawaja also said he spoke to David Warner and Pat Cummins, while Cameron Bancroft contacted him before publication. He said Smith had previously persuaded him not to speak publicly on his own, when he wanted the team to address the affair collectively. These are Khawaja's descriptions of the conversations.S1S2

Penguin lists the book's publication date as 10 November, and the podcast's own page is dated 15 November. AAP reports that the interview was recorded before Cummins's subsequent press conference rejecting Khawaja's claims. The newly published interview therefore should not be presented as a response to that press conference.R5R1R6

Why it matters

Khawaja alleges that knowledge of the 2018 ball-tampering plan extended beyond the three players Cricket Australia sanctioned. Cummins and Mitchell Starc deny knowing that sandpaper would be used, and former batting coach Graeme Hick also denies prior knowledge. Warner has supported Khawaja's account. The disagreement remains unresolved by these competing recollections.S1S2

The dispute about knowledge is separate from views on the punishment. Khawaja says Smith, Warner and Bancroft were treated unfairly. Cummins also described their penalties as too severe while denying advance knowledge of the sandpaper plan. Agreement about the penalties does not mean agreement about what happened.S2R4

The background

On 27 March 2018, Cricket Australia's then chief executive James Sutherland said its investigation had identified only Smith, Warner and Bancroft as having prior knowledge. The ICC's contemporary account records that announcement. Khawaja's allegation challenges that finding; it does not replace it with a new disciplinary determination.R2S1

The following day, Cricket Australia announced 12-month suspensions for Smith and Warner and a nine-month suspension for Bancroft. These covered international and domestic cricket. The ICC recorded the sanctions and the different conduct attributed to each player, including Smith's failure to prevent the plan and Bancroft's attempt to alter the ball.R3

Khawaja says he promised Warner in 2020 that he would eventually speak out but did not tell him the book's contents until two months before publication. He says he feared leaks and weighed the possible consequences for players still representing Australia. His view that the three sanctioned players were treated unfairly remains his assessment.S2

What happens next

Cricket Australia's website reports that chief executive Todd Greenberg has ruled out reopening the investigation. No new disciplinary ruling resolving the competing accounts is established by the material reviewed here. Smith's account of the specific private conversation described by Khawaja is also not established in these sources.R4S1S2