What happened

Two Democratic members of Congress have challenged the Navy over its handling of leadership changes aboard the nuclear-powered attack submarine USS South Dakota. In a letter released on 12 November, Joe Courtney of Connecticut and Adam Smith of Washington said the service had removed the commander, second-in-command and senior enlisted sailor without notifying the House Armed Services Committee.S1S2

Their letter went to acting Navy Secretary Hung Cao and Admiral Daryl Caudle, the Navy's senior uniformed officer. The lawmakers said the lack of communication raised questions about transparency and the Navy's working relationship with Congress. The Navy declined public comment when approached for the reports.S1S2

The Independent and Times of India described the removals as following a seabed collision. The letter itself calls a grounding alleged and asks whether one occurred; it does not establish a collision. USNI News separately reported that an unnamed defence official confirmed the removals.S1S2R1R3

Why it matters

The lawmakers describe notification as a longstanding custom, rather than an express statutory requirement. Their complaint concerns Congress's access to information as well as the personnel decisions themselves. They argue that the handling raised questions about the Navy's commitment to a productive working relationship with Congress.R2S1

Public announcements and communication with a congressional committee are separate parts of this dispute. The news reports describe a departure from the Navy's usual practice of announcing senior removals, while the lawmakers say their committee was also left uninformed. Those accounts do not explain why the Navy handled these changes differently.S1S2

The background

South Dakota entered service on 2 February 2019 as the Navy's seventeenth Virginia-class fast-attack submarine. USNI News reports that the three leadership removals took place on 14 October 2026, citing the lawmakers' account. It said the extent of any damage was unclear.R3R4

The reporting also describes separate personnel changes elsewhere in the service. According to an unnamed defence official quoted in the coverage, the Navy removed Commander Caitlin Cunningham from USS Michael Murphy on 27 September, citing loss of confidence. The reports said the service did not publicly announce that decision. The destroyer had been deployed to support operations against Iran, and Cunningham had held command for less than a year.S1S2

What happens next

Courtney and Smith requested answers by 20 November, including whether a mishap occurred and details of any damage or injuries. The reports also place the dispute ahead of Cao's expected confirmation hearing the following week. They do not establish what explanation the Navy will give or whether the hearing will address the submarine.R2S1S2