What happened

Darren Lehmann has again denied knowing that Australia used sandpaper on the ball during the 2018 tour of South Africa. Speaking on radio on Saturday, the former head coach disputed Cameron Bancroft’s account of his involvement while accepting responsibility for the team’s culture and apologising for what happened.S3S4S5

Bancroft alleged that Lehmann and bowling coach David Saker were present when David Warner proposed using sandpaper during the second Test at Port Elizabeth. He qualified that account by saying he could not speak for every word shared; their alleged presence does not establish either coach's agreement. Lehmann said he could not remember being present at that discussion.S4

Why it matters

A separate disagreement concerns an alleged walkie-talkie instruction to 12th man Peter Handscomb to remove the sandpaper after television cameras caught Bancroft with the sandpaper in Cape Town. Lehmann said he was “not sure” about the exchange, that the incident had already played out on television and that his view differed from Bancroft's.S3S4

Lehmann also described the personal consequences of the scandal. He said he had experienced a very difficult period and estimated that it took three or four years to regain some sense of normality. He expressed concern for others and their families, and said he did not want to return to that period of his life.S2

The background

The original disciplinary outcome remains part of the background to the renewed dispute. Cricket Australia’s investigation cleared Lehmann of wrongdoing in the Cape Town incident. He nevertheless announced his resignation on 29 March 2018, with the final Test of the South Africa series to be his last in charge.R1

Steve Smith and David Warner received 12-month suspensions from international and domestic cricket, while Bancroft received nine months. Bancroft alleged that knowledge of the plan extended beyond those three players. Cummins, Hazlewood and the other Australia bowlers who played in Cape Town have denied knowing about or being involved in the plan to use sandpaper.R2S3

The renewed debate followed allegations in Usman Khawaja’s autobiography that the whole team knew about the plan. Bancroft then published his detailed account in the West Australian on Wednesday. Lehmann left commentary duties that day when the account appeared, before returning for Saturday’s broadcast and answering questions about the allegations. Khawaja’s assertions that the whole team knew and should have taken responsibility have also received support from Warner, Chadd Sayers and Jon Holland.S3

What happens next

Cricket Australia has announced an independent forum for players and staff to give their accounts. Chief executive Todd Greenberg said participation would be voluntary, that the process was not a reinvestigation and that it was not designed to impose sanctions. The announcement provides a route for further testimony, but does not resolve the conflicting recollections already made public.R3