Some spin · most spun: Liverpool Echo 39/100 See every outlet’s spin ↓Photo as used by Liverpool Echo for “Martin Lewis says £8 item can slash bills and keep house warm”How Liverpool Echo framed it: Liverpool Echo uses a studio image of Martin Lewis, placing the money-saving expert at the centre of the story. The photograph reinforces his role as the source of the advice rather than illustrating the radiator shelf.
Martin Lewis has discussed changes to radiators, curtains and heating controls on his ITV programme. Energy Saving Trust guidance supports using purpose-made reflector panels on uninsulated external walls. The £8 shelf price quoted in coverage does not establish a particular bill reduction.
How the coverage differs
Liverpool Echo leads on radiator adjustments and is the only one of the three to include temperature advice and a caveat for older people or those with medical conditions. Manchester Evening News focuses on heating schedules, including expert qualifications about building type and heating appliance; the other two do not explore that debate. Daily Mirror alone leads on curtains and blinds and compares individual electric heaters with central heating.
Martin Lewis has urged households to check how their radiators and curtains are positioned as part of winter energy-saving advice on The Martin Lewis Money Show Live. Reports of the programme describe suggestions ranging from moving large furniture away from radiators to fitting reflector panels behind those mounted on external walls.S1S3
The Liverpool Echo highlights Lewis’s suggestion of a radiator shelf costing about £8. He said a shelf could direct heat towards the room rather than allowing it to rise straight upwards. That price is his quoted estimate for an item, not a measured saving on a household’s bill or a guaranteed current retail offer.S1
Why it matters
Energy Saving Trust gives a narrower explanation of where reflector panels help most: behind radiators on uninsulated external walls. It says panels on internal walls are generally not worthwhile because heat entering those walls stays within the home. The guidance recommends purpose-made panels rather than kitchen foil.R1
Its current estimate is that panels on uninsulated external walls can save £18 annually in Great Britain or £20 in Northern Ireland. Those figures concern reflector panels, not the shelf mentioned by Lewis. They should therefore not be presented as evidence that an £8 shelf will deliver the same saving.R1S1
The curtain advice is similarly about keeping heat in occupied space. The Mirror reports Lewis recommending open curtains when sunshine is entering and closing them after dark, while avoiding curtains hanging in front of a radiator. He warned that obstructing a radiator could leave it heating the fabric rather than the room.S3
The background
The programme also considered whether heating should stay on low throughout the day. Manchester Evening News quotes Lewis’s general advice to supply heat when needed, but Professor Richard Fitton qualified the answer according to weather and building construction. He contrasted heat-storing solid buildings with lighter structures and suggested households compare their own meter readings.S2
Heating engineer James Lacey added that the appliance and its controls also matter. Energy Saving Trust’s guide focuses on boiler-based central heating and explicitly directs heat-pump users to separate guidance. It recommends using controls to match heating to need and choosing the lowest comfortable room temperature, usually between 18°C and 21°C.S2R3
What happens next
Lewis suggested experimenting with a one-degree reduction while acknowledging that older people and those with medical conditions may need more warmth. Government cold-weather guidance says frequently occupied rooms should generally be heated to at least 18°C and stresses personal comfort. Its warning that low indoor temperatures can harm health qualifies any effort to cut heating costs.S1R2
Fact check: every point labelled
What is confirmed, what is only reported, and what is claim or speculation. Every point links to its source.
What we know
On the record or independently reported by more than one outlet.
confirmedEnergy Saving Trust's boiler-focused guidance directs heat-pump users elsewhere and recommends heating to need at the lowest comfortable temperature, usually 18–21°C.R3
confirmedGovernment guidance recommends at least 18°C in frequently occupied rooms and warns that low indoor temperatures can harm health, particularly for older people or those with medical conditions.R2
Reported but not yet confirmed
Reported as fact, but from a single origin.
reportedLiverpool Echo and Daily Mirror: Lewis discussed radiator placement, reflectors, shelves and curtains on his ITV programme.S1S3
reportedLiverpool Echo: Lewis suggested testing a one-degree reduction, noting that older people and those with medical conditions may need more warmth.S1
Claims and disputes
What people say. Not established fact.
claimedMartin Lewis: Radiator shelves can cost about £8 and redirect heat towards the room.S1
claimedEnergy Saving Trust: Purpose-made reflector panels are most effective on uninsulated external walls; internal-wall installations are generally not worthwhile, and kitchen foil is not recommended.R1
claimedEnergy Saving Trust: Reflector panels on uninsulated external walls can save £18 annually in Great Britain or £20 in Northern Ireland.R1
claimedMartin Lewis: Curtains should admit sunshine, close after dark and not obstruct radiators; furniture should be moved away from radiators.S1S3
claimedProfessor Richard Fitton: Heating schedules depend on weather and construction; households can compare meter readings.S2
claimedJames Lacey: The type of heating appliance and its controls affect how it should be used.S2
Still unknown
The bill saving any particular household would obtain from a radiator shelf.
Key questions
What is the £8 item Lewis mentioned?
A radiator shelf. The quoted price does not establish how much it would save on a particular bill.S1
Should reflector panels go behind every radiator?
Energy Saving Trust says they are most useful on uninsulated external walls and generally not worthwhile on internal walls.R1
Should everyone turn their thermostat down?
No single reduction suits everyone. Government guidance stresses comfort and recommends at least 18°C in frequently occupied rooms, with particular concern for older people and those with medical conditions.R2
Spin meter
How each outlet framed this story, scored on the wording and choices in that article, not on the outlet’s reputation.
Headlines compared: Liverpool Echo leads with the price of a radiator shelf and a promise of sharply lower bills. Manchester Evening News promises an answer to the heating-schedule debate, while Daily Mirror highlights a specific curtain tip.
Liverpool EchoFraming: Not political · Spin 39/100 · Headline matches story: partly
“Martin Lewis says £8 item can slash bills and keep house warm”
Straight reportingHeavy spin
Liverpool Echo emphasises an inexpensive radiator shelf and other ways to reduce heating costs, while including Lewis's temperature advice and caveats.
Why? 2 framing techniques
clickbait headline£8 item can slash bills The article identifies a radiator shelf costing about £8 but gives no figure showing how much it saves.
loaded languagedramatically cut heating bills The phrase promises substantial savings, although the article does not quantify the shelf's effect.
Manchester Evening NewsFraming: Not political · Spin 28/100 · Headline matches story: partly
“Martin Lewis settles debate on whether it's cheaper to leave heating on low all day”
Straight reportingHeavy spin
Manchester Evening News presents the heating-schedule question as settled in its headline but includes experts' qualifications and advice to experiment.
Why? 2 framing techniques
emphasisMartin Lewis settles debate The headline implies a definitive answer, while the experts say the outcome depends on the building and heating appliance.
omission The article does not mention government advice to keep frequently occupied rooms at least 18°C or the health risks of low indoor temperatures.
Daily MirrorFraming: Not political · Spin 23/100 · Headline matches story: yes
“Martin Lewis explains how to use your curtains to keep heat in your home this winter”
Straight reportingHeavy spin
Daily Mirror focuses on curtains and blinds before adding advice on heating one room rather than the whole home.
Why? 2 framing techniques
opinion as factthere's no one better than Martin Lewis The article presents praise for Lewis as a definitive assessment rather than an attributed opinion.
omission Alongside advice to heat a person or a single room, the article does not mention government minimum-temperature guidance or the health risks of cold indoor conditions.
Earlier coverage of similar events
How outlets reported related stories before this one. Compare for yourself.
This story was written and checked by AI agents using only the sources above, then published automatically. Facts are labelled by how well they are supported. If something is wrong, tell us: we check every report against the sources and publish corrections. Editorial policy