What happened

Ed Miliband has apologised again for appearing on Russell Brand's online show in 2015 and criticised a message in which Brand denied guilt after his imprisonment. The foreign secretary told Sky News that the comments showed no remorse or sympathy for the victims. His criticism followed Laura Gallacher reading a message attributed to her husband on Sunday.R6S4

On BBC Radio 4's Today programme on Monday, Miliband said he regretted the interview and would not have participated had he known the allegations, the BBC reported. He also said his sympathies were with the victims and that their voices should be heard. These were his explanations and views about his earlier decision. Asked about former shadow chancellor Ed Balls's reservations, he said he had not known about them at the time, the Guardian reported.S1S3

Why it matters

Sky presenter Sophie Ridge challenged Miliband's conditional explanation, calling it a "cop out" while accepting that the allegations were not known at the time. Her question concerned the wider culture surrounding Brand. Miliband responded that he had not been endorsing him and repeated his apology for taking part, according to the Express's account.S2

Miliband's explanation separates his participation in the interview from the position he says he intended to challenge. He told Sky he had been responding to Brand's argument against voting. When questioned about the wider culture surrounding Brand, he also said that media and politics should examine it.R6

Contemporaneous coverage offers a check on what was actually said in that exchange. ITV's report of 29 April 2015 describes a 15-minute interview on The Trews, filmed in Brand's London flat. It records Miliband rejecting Brand's argument that voting had become meaningless and arguing that political change required government as well as public action.R5

That record supports the narrower point that Miliband challenged Brand's views on voting during the interview. It does not establish everything Miliband knew at the time or his private reasons for taking part. His present explanation of his intentions remains his own account.R5R6

The background

Brand was convicted at Southwark Crown Court on 5 November of one rape and three sexual assaults involving four women, for offences between 2004 and 2009. He received ten years and six months on 9 November. The Metropolitan Police confirmed that he is subject to lifelong sex-offender registration.R2R3

The message read by Gallacher denied guilt, according to the reports of Sunday Service. That denial conflicts with the jury's verdicts. The episode's own description says Laura presented without Russell, included material recorded during the trial and ended with a message he had asked her to read.S4R2R4

What happens next

Miliband also supported debate about the age of consent, while describing a change in the law as a major step, according to the Independent's account of his BBC Breakfast interview. He said victims and their advocates should be heard. Those comments support discussion; they do not announce enacted legislation or a timetable for a bill.S4