What happened

Jodie Hatch and her partner Dale Mathie have been jailed following the death of Hatch's two-year-old daughter, Laylah. They were sentenced at Teesside Crown Court on 16 November after admitting child cruelty and drug offences. Hatch received five years and four months in prison.R1S3

Laylah died after ingesting cocaine that had contaminated her milk, Judge Francis Laird KC said, according to the Mail's court report. But he said the prosecution could not establish whether someone deliberately mixed the drug into the milk or whether it became contaminated by drugs in the flat. The sentencing account does not resolve that distinction.S3

The published accounts differ over Mathie's total sentence. Cleveland Police's release gives 13 years, while the Express and Mail report 13 years and nine months. His sentence also covered a separate violent incident, so the total should not be described as a sentence solely for the offences involving Laylah.R1S1S3

Why it matters

The convictions concern child cruelty and drug offences. The Express explicitly reports that neither defendant was convicted of causing Laylah's death. The judge's account of how she died must therefore be distinguished from the offences for which the two adults were sentenced.S1S3

Prosecutor Richard Wright KC told the court that drugs were stored openly and within reach in Mathie's flat. He said Laylah's exposure should have been apparent to both defendants because drugs were sold and consumed there. Mathie's barrister, John Elvidge KC, said his client maintained he had never taken drugs in front of children.S3

The background

Emergency services attended a Billingham address on 10 April 2024 after a report that Laylah was not breathing. She died at North Tees Hospital. Police said their search found cannabis and cocaine within a toddler's reach, and toxicology identified cocaine in her milk bottle and body. The force described the amount in the bottle as fatal, with further traces found in her blood, stomach contents and hair.R1

Both defendants initially denied two child-cruelty offences concerning Laylah and another child. Cleveland Police said they changed their pleas on the third day of trial. The Mail's court account dates the child-cruelty offences between September 2023 and April 2024.R1S3

The accounts also differ in how they describe Mathie's separate violence case. Police call it violent disorder, while the Mail's court report records guilty pleas to two counts of inflicting grievous bodily harm involving an attack on teenagers in Billingham in September 2025. The reviewed material does not explain that discrepancy or the difference in his reported sentence.R1S3