What happened

New York City’s Office of Chief Medical Examiner said on Monday that it stood by its ruling that Jeffrey Epstein died by suicide. Its statement came as Michael Freeman, a consultant in forensic medicine, presented a review of Epstein’s medical records at Middle Temple in London. Freeman argued that another person had caused the death.S3S8S10

Epstein’s brother Mark supplied the autopsy file. Freeman spent about a year examining the material, including photographs. He did not examine the body himself. At the time of his presentation, the analysis had not been published in a peer-reviewed journal.S3S5S9

Why it matters

Freeman argued that the distribution of injuries, including those to the neck and shoulder, was more consistent with an assault. Other forensic specialists who reviewed some of the photographs cautioned that an unusual mark did not rule out suicide and that the images alone could not establish the circumstances of death.S3S9

The city’s statement distinguished between the physical cause of death, which it recorded as hanging, and the manner of death, which it classified as suicide. Freeman’s presentation challenged that classification. The office that conducted the autopsy has retained its original finding.S3S8S10

The background

Epstein died in August 2019 at the Metropolitan Correctional Center in Manhattan. Two federal investigations followed different lines of inquiry. The FBI investigated whether anyone outside the Bureau of Prisons had committed a criminal act that caused the death. The Justice Department’s inspector general examined how prison staff had supervised and cared for a prisoner in their custody.S7R1

In June 2023 the inspector general reported serious failures at the jail, including missed checks and inaccurate records stating that rounds had taken place. The report also distinguished between camera feeds that staff could monitor live and the much more limited footage investigators were able to review afterwards. The review identified staffing shortages and management failures among the longstanding problems affecting the prison service.R1

The inspector general found no evidence contradicting the FBI’s conclusion that the death had not resulted from a criminal act. The review made eight recommendations for improving the management of federal prisons. The Bureau of Prisons agreed with all eight, according to the inspector general.R1

What happens next

Spencer Kuvin, a lawyer for some of Epstein’s victims, told the Daily Mirror that he wanted an independent examination of Freeman’s findings. He asked authorities to explain where the analysis agreed or conflicted with the official record and said Epstein’s death should not end scrutiny of people who may have enabled abuse.S5