What happened
Arsenal should have been awarded a penalty when Hull City’s Nobel Mendy held Kai Havertz at the Emirates Stadium on 7 November, the Premier League’s Key Match Incidents panel has found. All five members agreed that the holding happened before any offside offence. Arsenal won the match 1–0.S1S2R1R3
Referee Farai Hallam gave no penalty on the field. Michael Oliver, the video assistant referee, recommended that Hallam review the incident. The review took place, but Arsenal still did not receive a penalty because Havertz had been in an offside position.R1
Why it matters
The panel considered both stages of the decision. Its members agreed that Hallam should have given the penalty in the first place. They also agreed that a penalty should have been awarded after the review. Their finding turned on the order of events, rather than a different assessment of where Havertz was standing.R1S2
Law 11, published by the International Football Association Board, distinguishes an offside position from an offside offence. An attacker can be ahead of the ball and the second-last opponent when a team-mate plays the ball without necessarily committing an offence. The question is whether the attacker then becomes involved in active play. Law 11 also covers interference with an opponent. A player can become involved without touching the ball, for example by clearly blocking an opponent’s view and thereby preventing them from playing or being able to play the ball.R2
The background
The law gives a specific example of an attacker moving towards the ball with the intention of playing it. If an opponent fouls that attacker before the attacker plays or attempts to play the ball, or challenges an opponent for it, the referee penalises the foul.R2
The order can also work the other way round. If a player has already committed an offside offence before the opponent fouls them, the referee penalises the offside offence. In the Hull match, the panel placed Mendy’s hold first. It therefore judged that Havertz’s position did not cancel out the foul.R1R2
What happens next
The Premier League describes the Key Match Incidents panel as an independent group of five. Three members are former players or coaches. The league and Professional Game Referees, known as Pro Ref, each have one representative. The group assesses decisions made by match officials.R3
In this case the video assistant had already recommended another look at the incident. The panel’s criticism concerned the decision to leave Arsenal without a penalty after that review as well as the original on-field call. Both parts of the retrospective assessment were unanimous.R1