What happened

The Daily Record and Daily Express published accounts on 19 November of comments by Charmaine van Wyk, a forensic pathologist at Sefako Makgatho Health Sciences University in South Africa. Both attributed her remarks to an interview with Newsweek. Neither described a new study or presented measurements comparing different deaths.S1S2

Van Wyk gave the example of necklacing, a form of killing associated with political violence in South Africa during apartheid. In explaining her choice, she placed particular weight on how long a person might remain aware of suffering. That was the basis of her judgement about the example she chose.S1S2

Why it matters

A comparison of the two reports traces the judgement back to one speaker. The Express also credited the Daily Star in its account of the Newsweek interview. The International Association for the Study of Pain defines pain in terms of the individual’s experience.S1S2R1

The International Association for the Study of Pain revised its definition in 2020. It describes pain as having both sensory and emotional dimensions. The association says biology, psychology and social circumstances all influence an individual’s experience, and that activity in sensory nerves alone cannot tell an observer what someone feels.R1

The change also addressed how clinicians understand people who cannot speak about their experience. The earlier definition had been interpreted as excluding infants and others unable to describe pain in words. The revised guidance says a person may experience pain even when unable to communicate it, and asks clinicians to respect a person’s own account.R1

In notes accompanying the definition, the association describes how pain can affect a person’s ability to carry out everyday activities and can have consequences for their psychological and social well-being. The notes also explain that people learn what pain means through their own experiences.R1

The background

The reports place the killings in South African townships in the mid-to-late 1980s. They describe people being targeted on suspicion of collaborating with the apartheid state and say accusations could arise from rumour or personal disputes. Suspicion in those accounts was no proof of collaboration.S1S2

South Africa’s Truth and Reconciliation Commission recorded the harm of political violence through statements and hearings. Its Human Rights Violations Committee investigated abuses between 1960 and 1994. Its remit included identifying victims, establishing their fate and documenting the extent of the harm they suffered.R2

The commission referred people it identified as victims of gross human rights violations to its Reparation and Rehabilitation Committee. That committee was charged with supporting victims and making recommendations for survivors, their families and communities. The commission’s public archive includes transcripts of victim hearings and submissions from organisations.R2