What happened

Proposed changes to HMRC's information powers have prompted questions about whether taxpayers' conversations with AI tools could be requested during tax checks. The government has published draft amendments to section 114 of the Finance Act 2008, which deals with computer records. The draft changes its heading to digital information and broadens the description of where relevant information can be found.R1S2

Matthew Holman, a partner at law firm Cripps, told City AM that wider definitions could bring AI histories within scope, although the bill does not explicitly enable access to them. That is an assessment of the proposal's possible reach, not evidence that HMRC is already routinely examining private chatbot conversations.S2

Why it matters

HMRC told the Independent that it wants to understand how relevant tax figures are produced, including through software and automated processes. Its spokesperson said requests still need an existing lawful basis and rejected the suggestion that the changes concern everyone's use of large language models.S1

The distinction matters for people and businesses using tools such as ChatGPT, Claude or Copilot to help prepare tax calculations. The Independent raises whether prompts and conversations forming part of that process could become disclosable. It does not establish that all conversations on an account would be relevant to a tax enquiry.S1

Anne Strickland of the Taxpayers' Alliance argued that requiring private AI conversations would intrude on privacy and urged ministers to stop the change. Nicola Cain of consultancy Handley Gill told City AM that access would still have to be necessary and proportionate. Those concerns focus on how requests would be limited in practice.S2

The background

HMRC already uses information notices to check tax positions or collect tax debts. Its compliance handbook requires requested material to be reasonably required for those purposes. The handbook also describes appeal rights, with exceptions for statutory records in tax-position checks and notices approved in advance by a tribunal.R3

The penalties mentioned in news coverage also appear in existing HMRC guidance. Non-compliance can attract £300, with a reasonable-excuse safeguard. Carelessly or deliberately supplying inaccurate information can attract up to £3,000 per inaccuracy; HMRC says disclosure of an error when supplying the information avoids that penalty, and errors discovered later must be reported promptly.R4

What happens next

The official policy paper ties commencement to Royal Assent to Finance Bill 2026–27, without specifying a calendar date. It says section 114 remains a supporting provision, creates no standalone information power and retains existing safeguards. City AM anticipates assent in March, while the Independent expects commencement in May: neither month is fixed by the official paper reviewed.R2S1S2

The precise treatment of particular AI conversations remains unresolved in the supplied material. Holman's assessment is that broader definitions could include them; it does not settle what a valid request would cover in an individual case.S2