What happened

Red Bull New York’s 1–0 friendly win over Club América on Saturday ended with a confrontation and dismissals. The match took place at Sports Illustrated Stadium in Harrison, New Jersey. Nehuen Benedetti scored the only goal, according to the home club’s match report.R1R4S1S2

The Guardian and the New York Post describe trouble near the end of the second half after a foul close to the corner of the pitch. The Guardian identifies the fouled player as Mijahir Jimenez. Both outlets report punches and objects thrown from the crowd, while the Post places the incident in the 85th minute.S1S2

The reports disagree with the club’s account over how many players were dismissed. Both news outlets give a total of five: two from New York and three from América. The Red Bulls’ recap instead says each side finished with eight players after three dismissals apiece. The accounts reviewed do not reconcile that difference.S1S2R1

Why it matters

The discrepancy affects the disciplinary record of the match, even though the sources agree on the New York win. The club recap does not identify the dismissed players or set out the referee’s reasons. It therefore cannot be used to confirm the individual dismissal list supplied by the Post.R1S2

Football’s laws provide some context for the reduced numbers. The International Football Association Board’s Law 3 says a match cannot continue if either team has fewer than seven players. It also says a player sent off after kick-off cannot be replaced. Eight players on each side would remain above that minimum.R5

Speaking afterwards, coach Michael Bradley discussed the intensity of such matches. “You hear people say that there are no real friendlies,” he said, as quoted by the Post, before describing players’ desire to compete and win. The report does not establish a disciplinary ruling beyond the match itself.S2

The background

Benedetti’s winner came in the 59th minute. The club says Rafael Mosquera crossed, Julian Bazán’s volley was stopped by goalkeeper Rodolfo Cota, and Benedetti converted the rebound. The goal was Benedetti’s first for New York across all competitions. AJ Marcucci also made his first start since a knee injury on 13 August 2025.R1

New York had added eight players from its second team on short-term agreements for the friendly. Its starting-line-up announcement also records that the club had ended its MLS regular season with a 3–0 win over Atlanta United on 7 November. Those preparations place Saturday’s game after the league programme had finished for New York.R2R3