What happened
Sotheby's is in discussions with heirs of the Fischer family over the planned sale of Vincent van Gogh's Châtaigniers en fleurs, also known as Blossoming Chestnut Trees. The BBC reports that their representatives believe the painting may have been sold under duress during the rise of the Nazis.S2
The work is scheduled for auction in New York on Wednesday, 18 November, as part of the Blaquier-Arrieta Collection. The BBC puts its estimate at $180 million, or £136 million. Sotheby's public lot page currently gives the estimate as available on request, so neither figure is a completed sale price.S2R1R3
In a statement to the BBC, Sotheby's said its research had not established that the painting was sold under duress. It also acknowledged the heirs' concerns and said it was working towards a resolution acceptable to both sides. That response does not announce a settlement or a decision to withdraw the work.S2
Why it matters
The dispute concerns the circumstances in which ownership changed, rather than simply whether a sale appears in the historical record. The BBC, citing the New York Times, reports that the heirs' lawyer linked the sale to losses suffered by the family's publishing business under Nazi rule. That account remains an attributed allegation.S2
International restitution guidance helps explain why those circumstances matter. The 2024 best practices accompanying the Washington Principles say sales under duress can fall within the definition of Nazi-confiscated art. They also say sales by persecuted people between 1933 and 1945 can amount to involuntary transfers, depending on the specific historical and legal circumstances.R2
Those principles are legally non-binding and operate within countries' legal systems. They provide a framework for examining claims and seeking fair solutions, rather than a ruling on this painting. The materials reviewed do not establish whether the Fischer family's sale met the relevant conditions.R2S2
The background
Sotheby's dates the oil painting to 24 May 1890 in Auvers. According to the ownership history described by the BBC, German publisher Samuel Fischer acquired the painting in 1909 and it passed down within his family after his death in 1934. It had been deposited with Paul Cassirer in Amsterdam in 1932 or 1933, before passing to Henriette and Marcel Kapferer in Paris in 1936.S2R1
What happens next
Sotheby's stated next step is continued discussion with the heirs' representatives. Whether those talks produce an agreement before the scheduled auction remains unresolved. The sources reviewed provide no agreed settlement terms and no court determination of the duress allegation.S2R3
