What happened

Tony Butala, a founding member of The Lettermen, died on 1 November, the group's media coordinator, Tracy Clark, confirmed to the Associated Press. Clark shared a band statement announcing his death. No cause of death was disclosed.S1S3

The Associated Press reported that Butala was 87 and was born in Sharon, Pennsylvania, in 1938. However, a Cash Box profile published in April 1962 gives his birth date as 20 November 1940. The supplied records do not resolve that discrepancy.S3R6

Why it matters

Butala was the last surviving member of the original trio, according to the Associated Press. His fellow founders, Bob Engemann and Jim Pike, died in 2013 and 2019 respectively. Butala's death does not mark the end of the performing group: its reported current members are Donovan Tea, Bobby Poynton and Rob Gulack.S3

Recording Academy records list four Grammy nominations for The Lettermen and no wins. They date the nomination for the medley “Goin’ Out of My Head/Can’t Take My Eyes Off You” to 1969. News accounts identify it as a 1968 Top 10 hit: its chart success and Grammy nomination fall in different years.R2S2S3

The background

According to the Associated Press account, Butala began singing professionally at seven, appeared on Pittsburgh's KDKA Radio at eight and moved to Los Angeles with his mother at ten. There he joined the Mitchell Boys Choir. He later formed The Lettermen with Pike and Engemann in the late 1950s.S3

Their first hit was their 1961 recording of “The Way You Look Tonight”, which reached number 13 on Billboard's Hot 100, according to the news accounts. A biography filed with the Los Angeles city clerk says the recording was originally the B-side of “That’s My Desire”. That account credits listener requests with helping turn it into a radio hit.S2S3R3

Butala's work also extended beyond the trio. The Vocal Group Hall of Fame Foundation says he conceived the idea for the institution in the early 1960s and opened its hall and museum with a financial partner in Sharon in 1998. The Lettermen later received a Hollywood Walk of Fame star in 2020; the Hollywood Chamber of Commerce says the group's fan club nominated and sponsored it.R5S3R4

What happens next

The Lettermen's own announcement dates Butala's departure from performing to May 2019 and says he helped prepare for the group to continue. News accounts describe successive line-ups that retained the three-singer format after members left. The group continued after Butala stopped performing.R1S3

The band's statement said there would be no public viewing. It said details of celebrations of his life in Wisconsin and California would be announced later. Dates and venues were not provided in the supplied reports.S1S2S3