Trump calls Iran memorandum a ‘waste of time’ but says pursuing it was no mistake
During a visit to China, Donald Trump criticised the preliminary agreement that JD Vance helped negotiate and said he would have preferred to go straight to a contract.
Some spin · most spun: Daily Mirror 40/100 See every outlet’s spin ↓Photo as used by Daily Mirror for “Trump dismisses JD Vance's Iran deal as 'a waste of time' during China visit”How Daily Mirror framed it: The Daily Mirror's lead photo shows Trump speaking into a microphone with a serious expression. It reinforces the focus on his remarks rather than on the memorandum's contents.
Donald Trump criticised the US memorandum of understanding with Iran in a Fox News interview on 18 November. Asked whether pursuing it had been a mistake, he said it had given the US time to get to know the Iranian negotiators.
How the coverage differs
Both of the two supplied articles lead on Trump–Vance tensions and quote Trump saying the memorandum was not a mistake. Both attribute his affirmative answer about acting again to the memorandum; neither supplies the longer exchange's context about Vance's assessment of the war and elections. Neither explains the document's interim provisions or its distinction between preliminary talks and a final agreement. The Daily Mirror additionally discusses Vance's possible 2028 ambitions and later mediation and strike comments, while the Daily Express includes Democratic plans for congressional scrutiny.
Donald Trump called the US memorandum of understanding with Iran a “waste of time” during a Fox News interview in China on 18 November. When correspondent Jacqui Heinrich asked whether the agreement had been a mistake, the US president said it had not. Vice President JD Vance had helped negotiate the memorandum.S1S2R1
Trump said his preference was to go straight to a contract. He said he had listened to advisers despite his reservations about using a memorandum and acknowledged that the approach could have worked. In his view, the time spent with the Iranian representatives had also given US negotiators grounds to distrust them.S1S2
Why it matters
The difference between the preliminary document and a final agreement is set out in the text reproduced by the American Presidency Project. It envisaged negotiations lasting up to 60 days. The two sides could extend that period by mutual consent. A House of Commons Library briefing described the June memorandum as a framework for wider talks.R2R3
Several of the most consequential decisions were left for those talks. The text put the timetable for lifting sanctions within the final agreement. It also called for discussions about enrichment. In the interim it called for Iran to maintain the existing state of its nuclear programme and for the US to refrain from imposing new sanctions.R2
The background
The immediate provisions included arrangements for commercial shipping between the Persian Gulf and the Sea of Oman. The text called for Iran to use its best efforts to provide free and safe passage for commercial vessels for 60 days. It provided for talks with Oman on future arrangements for the Strait of Hormuz.R2
The document also made the start of negotiations on other provisions conditional on implementation of specified initial measures. The Commons Library said in its briefing that the text described to journalists and the version released by Iran were similar. Its account distinguished the commitments in the memorandum from the further discussions needed for a final deal.R2R3
What happens next
The Mirror and the Express also quoted Trump saying he would act the same way again. Both describe that answer as referring to the memorandum. In the longer exchange reported by the Daily Beast, Trump framed the question himself while discussing Vance’s assessment of the war and its electoral consequences.S1S2R1
Trump defended his administration’s approach, saying he believed it would be judged favourably in the longer term. His direct answer about whether the memorandum itself had been a mistake was that it had delayed matters but had given the Americans an opportunity to assess the people across the table.S1S2R1
Fact check: every point labelled
What is confirmed, what is only reported, and what is claim or speculation. Every point links to its source.
What we know
On the record or independently reported by more than one outlet.
confirmedDonald Trump called the US memorandum of understanding with Iran a “waste of time” during a Fox News interview in China on 18 November.S1S2R1
confirmedWhen correspondent Jacqui Heinrich asked whether the agreement had been a mistake, the US president said it had not.S1S2R1
confirmedVice President JD Vance had helped negotiate the memorandum.S1S2R1
confirmedThe difference between the preliminary document and a final agreement is set out in the text reproduced by the American Presidency Project.R2R3
confirmedIt envisaged negotiations lasting up to 60 days.R2R3
confirmedThe two sides could extend that period by mutual consent.R2R3
confirmedA House of Commons Library briefing described the June memorandum as a framework for wider talks.R2R3
confirmedSeveral of the most consequential decisions were left for those talks.R2
confirmedThe text put the timetable for lifting sanctions within the final agreement.R2
confirmedIt also called for discussions about enrichment.R2
confirmedIn the interim it called for Iran to maintain the existing state of its nuclear programme and for the US to refrain from imposing new sanctions.R2
confirmedThe immediate provisions included arrangements for commercial shipping between the Persian Gulf and the Sea of Oman.R2
confirmedThe text called for Iran to use its best efforts to provide free and safe passage for commercial vessels for 60 days.R2
confirmedIt provided for talks with Oman on future arrangements for the Strait of Hormuz.R2
confirmedThe document also made the start of negotiations on other provisions conditional on implementation of specified initial measures.R2R3
confirmedThe Commons Library said in its briefing that the text described to journalists and the version released by Iran were similar.R2R3
confirmedIts account distinguished the commitments in the memorandum from the further discussions needed for a final deal.R2R3
confirmedThe Mirror and the Express also quoted Trump saying he would act the same way again.S1S2R1
confirmedBoth describe that answer as referring to the memorandum.S1S2R1
confirmedIn the longer exchange reported by the Daily Beast, Trump framed the question himself while discussing Vance’s assessment of the war and its electoral consequences.S1S2R1
Speculation and opinion
Predictions and views, kept apart from the facts.
opinionDonald Trump: Trump said his preference was to go straight to a contract.S1S2
opinionDonald Trump: He said he had listened to advisers despite his reservations about using a memorandum and acknowledged that the approach could have worked.S1S2
opinionDonald Trump: In his view, the time spent with the Iranian representatives had also given US negotiators grounds to distrust them.S1S2
opinionDonald Trump: Trump defended his administration’s approach, saying he believed it would be judged favourably in the longer term.S1S2R1
opinionDonald Trump: His direct answer about whether the memorandum itself had been a mistake was that it had delayed matters but had given the Americans an opportunity to assess the people across the table.S1S2R1
Still unknown
Will the US and Iran resume negotiations on a final agreement?
Key questions
Did Trump call the memorandum a mistake?
He criticised the time it took but explicitly rejected describing it as a mistake.S1S2R1
What was the timetable for talks?
The text envisaged a final agreement within 60 days, extendable by mutual consent.R2
Was sanctions relief fully settled?
The text left the schedule to the final agreement.R2
Spin meter
How each outlet framed this story, scored on the wording and choices in that article, not on the outlet’s reputation.
Headlines compared: Both headlines foreground Trump criticising a memorandum associated with Vance. The Daily Mirror calls it a dismissal of the deal, while the Daily Express more directly presents it as a personal jibe.
“Trump dismisses JD Vance's Iran deal as 'a waste of time' during China visit”
Straight reportingHeavy spin
The Daily Mirror framed Trump's remarks as a rebuke to Vance, while including his statement that the memorandum was not a mistake.
Why? 4 framing techniques
loaded languageslammed his Vice President JD Vance's memorandum The verb heightens the impression of a personal attack, although Trump criticised the memorandum rather than explicitly attacking Vance.
emphasisTrump dismisses JD Vance's Iran deal The headline foregrounds a Trump–Vance conflict rather than Trump's qualification that the memorandum was not a mistake.
omission The article leaves out the memorandum's interim commitments and its distinction between a framework and a final agreement.
emphasiswhen asked if he would pursue the memorandum again The article links Trump's affirmative answer specifically to the memorandum without the longer exchange's context about Vance's assessment of the war and elections.
“Donald Trump takes aim at JD Vance with 'waste of time' jibe during China visit”
Straight reportingHeavy spin
The Daily Express presented the remarks as a jibe at Vance, while also reporting Trump's qualification and his affirmative answer about acting again.
Why? 4 framing techniques
loaded languagetakes aim at JD Vance The headline casts criticism of the memorandum as a personal attack on Vance, whom Trump did not explicitly criticise in the quoted remarks.
emphasisHe condemned the vice president's deal This emphasises Vance's ownership of the agreement over Trump's qualification that it was not a mistake.
omission The article does not explain the memorandum's interim commitments or distinguish its framework for talks from a final agreement.
emphasiswhen questioned whether he would pursue the memorandum again The article attributes Trump's affirmative answer specifically to the memorandum without the longer exchange's context about Vance's assessment of the war and elections.
Earlier coverage of similar events
How outlets reported related stories before this one. Compare for yourself.
Help power NoDirection. Read without adverts.Your support helps cover our AI costs and ongoing development—improving how we compare coverage, check sources and explain the news.from £3 a month, no adverts while signed inThanks for powering NoDirection. You’re reading without adverts.
This story was written and checked by AI agents using only the sources above, then published automatically. Facts are labelled by how well they are supported. If something is wrong, tell us: we check every report against the sources and publish corrections. Editorial policy