What happened
A three-judge federal appeals panel heard arguments on 16 November over Donald Trump's effort to move his New York hush-money case into federal court. The hearing at the Second Circuit followed arguments before the state's Appellate Division on 5 November. Those proceedings concern the same conviction through different legal routes.S1S2S3
The state case is a conventional appeal against the conviction. The federal proceeding concerns where the case can be heard, with Trump seeking an opportunity to argue for dismissal on presidential-immunity grounds. Moving a case between courts and overturning its verdict are distinct steps in that strategy.S1S2R2R3
Why it matters
At Monday's hearing, lawyer Robert Giuffra Jr asked the federal judges to intervene quickly, according to the Associated Press. Manhattan prosecutor Steven Wu urged them to leave the case in state court. Chief Judge Raymond Lohier questioned whether Congress had authorised the proposed procedure.R3
The Supreme Court's July 2024 immunity ruling distinguishes different types of presidential conduct. It provides absolute protection for actions within exclusive constitutional authority, at least presumptive protection for other official acts, and no immunity for unofficial acts. That distinction makes the nature of the conduct important; holding presidential office alone does not resolve every immunity question.R2
The background
Judge Alvin Hellerstein rejected the renewed removal request on 28 August 2026. His written ruling found no sufficient new grounds and no showing of the required good cause and diligence. It followed a November 2025 appellate remand directing him to reconsider the request, rather than ordering that the case be transferred.R1
The sentencing record establishes what Trump is challenging: a conviction on 34 counts of falsifying business records in the first degree. On 10 January 2025, Judge Juan Merchan imposed an unconditional discharge. That entered a judgment of conviction without a prison term or probation; it did not acquit Trump or erase the jury's verdict.R1R4
At sentencing, Merchan explained that the protection afforded to the presidency had shaped the available outcome. The prosecutor had recommended the same unconditional discharge. Trump nevertheless maintained in court that the case should not have been brought, so the absence of a custodial penalty did not end his challenge to the conviction.R4
What happens next
The Associated Press reports that the federal panel gave no immediate decision, while the state appeal also remained undecided. Giuffra argued that the trial had used protected official-act evidence, including Oval Office conversations and social-media posts. That is the defence's legal argument, not a finding that the appellate judges have accepted.R3S1
