What happened

The US Supreme Court has allowed the Trump administration to resume construction of border barriers, roads and related infrastructure in Texas’s Big Bend region. Its order on 9 November suspended an injunction issued by US District Judge Kathleen Cardone in October while litigation continues. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson indicated she would have denied the government’s request, without giving written reasons.S4S9S10R2

The construction programme extends beyond Big Bend National Park to state and private land. Although several headlines describe a wall through the park, ABC News reports that plans inside the park changed after public opposition to vehicle barriers, roads and surveillance technology. Fox News also reports that the park’s planned barrier will not use the 30-foot steel pedestrian fencing proposed elsewhere.S2S4S5S7S9

Why it matters

The order turns principally on the district court’s power to hear a particular legal argument, rather than a final assessment of the construction programme. The Supreme Court said the government was highly likely to establish that the lower court lacked jurisdiction over the plaintiffs’ major-questions claim. It described that doctrine as a rule for interpreting legislation, not a constitutional claim.R1

Both sides warned of irreversible consequences: the government from halting construction, and the plaintiffs from allowing it to proceed before a final judgment. Solicitor General D. John Sauer argued that stopping work would weaken border security and risk directing crossings and trafficking towards Big Bend. The plaintiffs argued that damage to habitats, historic resources, private property and livelihoods could not be undone by a later ruling.S10

The Court also relied in part on a Customs and Border Protection official’s declaration that the injunction was causing nearly $500,000 a day in unrecoverable expenses. That figure is the government official’s assessment cited in the order, rather than an independently established final cost.R3

The background

The plaintiffs include the Center for Biological Diversity, Friends of the Ruidosa Church and a local river guide and landowner. Their lawsuit challenges Department of Homeland Security waivers used to bypass environmental and conservation requirements. A 1996 immigration law gives the department’s secretary waiver powers for expedited border construction and restricts district-court challenges to constitutional claims.S4S7S10

The plaintiffs’ filing also raises separate constitutional arguments involving nondelegation, presentment, presidential execution of the law and due process. Those claims are distinct from the major-questions argument addressed in the stay order. National Park Service records provide another measure of the area’s use: Big Bend National Park recorded 568,104 recreational visits in 2025, up from 388,290 in 2016; these are visits, not distinct visitors.R1R4R5

What happens next

The government asked for either a stay or summary reversal; the Court granted a stay. Under its terms, the stay expires if a timely petition for review is denied, or when the Court issues its judgment if review is granted. The ruling therefore permits construction during further proceedings without finally resolving the lawsuit.R2S10